The Dismantling of War
by Catherine Browning
Kuwait, Arabian Gulf
May, 2003
They took down the wooden
boards today--the ones that barricaded our apartment from enemy assault.
There is still a small room off to the corner of the lobby which is
boarded up and closed tight with locks. That sequestered space was
where we women and children were going to be ushered into during an
invasion, assuring our safety from violating males. I will be relieved
when they dismantle that space too.
Elsewhere in Kuwait, they
have removed the heavy armored tanks and machine gun posts from the
entrances to the downtown area. Even the road blocks are few these
days and one can roam about the country with little fear of being
questioned. A few days ago I waved at one of the last visible Kuwaiti
soldiers keeping watch. As our car drove past the serious gentleman
in uniform, I flashed a big American smile and waved a friendly hello.
My friend, protecting me from possible disappointment, said
He won't be able to respond back. Seconds later, though,
the soldier gave me a timid little wave. It made my day. Things are
finally getting back to normal.
I can actually sleep at night
now without the terrifying sound of military jets screaming past my
apartment building. I never knew for sure if these flying machines
were friend or foe and the eerie mechanical screech made me think
of 9/11 over and over again. It would be so easy for an aircraft to
crash into my building. There are 5 blocks (apartment buildings) all
clustered together on the security-guarded, Kuwait University campus.
All of us who live here are lecturers, instructors, or professors
at the university. Our buildings are out in the middle of nowhere
and are a tall, visible target for anyone flying by.
On the outside our blocks
are beige, like everything else in Kuwait, but inside the homes are
bursting with the colorful life of families from around the world--Egypt,
Jordan, Palestine, India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Phillipines, Great
Britain, Canada, and America. There are only a few of us Americans
left. There were never too many of us to begin with, but now we are
down to about 4 or 5. I live in Block # 3. My neighbors are all Arabs
with delightful children who wave excitedly to me every time I venture
out of my home. They find my blue eyes and white skin to be a constant
source of amusement. Lately, I too have been finding my Caucasian
features to be amusing. They stand out so blatantly heresuch
a contrast to the dark-skinned, dark-eyed beauties of the East.
Some people here have a strong
superstition about blue eyes. They think these orbs are associated
with the evil eye. When glancing at me, they whisper masha'allah,
meaning Allah protect me from the evil eye. I have one
student in the classroom who refuses to look into my eyes for too
long and who has forbidden me to wear blue when around her because
this accentuates my cat eyes. Last week, while having
a conference with her, I had to keep looking at the floor because
she became increasingly anxious during our conversation. I asked her
Are my eyes bothering you? Yes,miss,
she replied shyly. Do not worry, sweetheart, I told her.
Allah made my eyes just like Allah made your eyes. Still,
I tried to look at her as little as possible so that I would not upset
her unnecessarily. As she left my office I heard her whisper
masha'allah....
My office is walking distance
from my apartment so on days when I don't feel safe to venture any
further, I cocoon myself on campus. During the last Gulf War, Saddam
Hussein's soldiers took over all of the apartments here and made this
place their Kuwaiti headquarters, of course after thoroughly looting
everything in site. You can still see bullet holes in many of the
buildings, haunting reminders of the once-powerful Iraqi regime. Also
down the street from me is a ship graveyard. Lying stuck, sideways,
in the middle of smelly mud flats, are tattered ships abandoned during
Gulf War I. They are unintentional reminders of the wreckage
of war.
I went back to America the
day before the commencement of Gulf War II. I was safely sequestered
in the United States for the next 2 weeks while those still in Kuwait
endured terrifying multiple air raid sirens each day, near-miss
missile threats, and chemical weapon scares. The most visible sign
here of the wreckage from Operation Iraqi Freedom is the Souq Sharq
which was blasted by a missile launched from a boat in the Kuwait
Bay. This is the market place where I normally go shopping every week.
The first thing I did when I returned here from the U.S. was to visit
the damage. Seeing the wreckage on CNN news was one thing, but actually
going to that familiar site and realizing I could have been standing
in that very spot during the attack, was another. I was shocked by
the damage--not because it was so extensive, but because I felt personally
violated. That missile tore into MY shopping center. That missile
penetrated MY favorite place. That missile blew-up the comfortable
seats in MY movie theatre. I guess war shatters us of our illusions
of possessiveness. Nothing in this life is permanent. Everything is
always subject to change, whether that change is well charted or impulsively
exploded.
As the Blackhawk helicopters
fade into the background and the convoy of army trucks become less
visible, the camouflage portrait of war begins to dissolve. Soldiers
return home on leave, the throng of news reporters flee to other battling
lands, and peace slowly returns to the scene. The panorama becomes
serene, almost as if those blaring sounds and daring threats had never
riled this part of the world. Yes, in Kuwait, at least, things are
finally getting back to normal.
But the wreckage, good God,
the wreckage of war, more must be said about that. The Iraqi people
are still without food, water, electricity, and medicine. Havoc rules
their land. Ancient treasures have been pillaged, perhaps permanently
erased from the historical landscape of earliest civilization. Animals
in the zoo have starved to death. And little Ali, the much-publicized
Iraqi boy, whose flesh burned away on his chest, whose arms are now
nothing more than 3 inch stubs, what will ever help his life get back
to normal?
Through some kind of strange
fate which seems to rule my life while I live in this region of the
world, I stood by Ali's side last week, and looked into his dazed,
haunted eyes. As the doctors in the intensive care room yanked the
dead tissue from his torso as caringly as they could, I wanted to
scream. Even with anesthesia, Ali moaned and yelled with each surgical
prod. My students and I locked eyes, inquiring of each other Is
this moment really happening? Even the girl so afraid
to gaze into my cat eyes, looked imploringly into my baby blues Why
does this little boy have to suffer so? Being a new mother,
she felt the agony of this child's pain as if it were her own.
Under normal circumstances
I couldn't tell you about my experience with this patient. Ethics
of confidentiality would prohibit such confessions. But Ali is a public
figure now; he belongs to the world. Besides, war does not exactly
qualify as under normal circumstances. Sometimes the ethics
of the universe transcend the ethics of human beings. I want
you to know what I saw when I looked into that child's eyes. I want
you to feel what I felt when I spoke with this child's uncle, the
only relative left alive to take Ali into his care.
I saw all the pain of humankind
in Ali's bleary eyes. I saw the degrading manner in which real, flesh
and blood human solutions rob us of joy. I saw that I had absolutely
no response to his probing, to his searching for answers. He wasn't
afraid of the way in which the evil eye might have infiltrated my
blue eyes. He stared me down until I felt completely stripped of my
own flesh. Superstitions are child's play to someone who has seen
all of their loved ones blown to smitherings. And pat answers are
repulsive to someone who is writhing in broiled pain. Ali forced me
to be humble. His tortured eyes became a mirror for me to see how
little I truly understand about life. Just when I think I have it
all figured out I discover that I don't know anything at all. So
much of life is a mystery and so much of life is slipping away in
useless decay, despite my best intentions. The only thing I had to
give Ali during his moment of need was this profound recognition that
I can, of myself, do nothing. It is only through the Creator that
healing is possible, that sense can be made out of complete chaos,
that beauty can be restored to that which is permanently scarred for
life. That's what I communicated to Ali with my cat-like eyes, that's
what hope I held onto as he bravely confronted every inch of my American
being.
As I held letters, gifts,
emails, cards, and prayers sent to him from around the world, I realized
that the Divine One would go to all extremes to assure this fragile,
frightened, abandoned child that he is not alone. As I exchanged words
with his uncle, through an Arab translator, I took my one, and probably
only chance, to make amends. As he described the way in which the
American missile blew up 16 homes and left so many children orphaned
and deformed, I stayed with him in his pain. As he angrily, cooly
said Ali is only one child; there are others, I nodded
with compassion.
As health care personnel
around me, due to their own discomfort, adamantly urged me to leave
the poor man alone I said No! Words must be said. I lingered
on and told the uncle that on behalf of all my family and friends,
on behalf of my country, I was so sorry for the loss that had come
to him, his family, his country. I told him that every American
I know would feel the same compassion I was feeling for he and his
nephew. After he vented his quiet rage, after we struggled through
a very difficult conversation, our eyes locked and through both of
our tears, a divine presence suddenly was felt. It was Allah in our
midst. You could feel it. It was the incredible, indelible sign of
the presence of the divine.
And with this caressing moment
of the Creator cradling this grown man, hope suddenly blossomed. We
both realized, on some deep level, that Allah was there, speaking
through me to him. And then he set the rage aside, and warmly told
me he understood America was trying to rescue the Iraqi people from
all the oppression caused by the Saddam regime. He said he forgave
America for the wayward missile that destroyed his innocent family
and friends. He expressed gratitude for the hundreds upon hundreds
of gifts and communications he has received from people in America
regarding the suffering of his young Ali. He expressed his gratitude
to American soldiers who airlifted Ali to Kuwait and to Kuwait for
paying all of Ali's medical care. He said he knew, in time, all would
be well, insha'allah (according to God's will). And through
that expression of forgiveness and profound faith I knew that Allah
was also speaking to me through him.
God was speaking to all of
us through him. Allah forgives us for whatever we did or failed to
do regarding this Iraqi war. We all did the best we could. Every American
soldier, every Bush cabinet member, every news correspondent, every
human shield, every Baath renegade, every Iraqi looter--we all did
the best we could given the extremely challenging and perverse conditions
under which we suddenly found ourselves.
War is a very perverse situation
indeed. It is an ugly depiction of human creativity at its worst.
It is this portrait, this distorted artwork, which should be plundered
and stolen from the annals of civilization. It is this phenomena which
should be dismantled permanently so that no child shall ever again
beg with his desperate eyes Please let me die. I want
to believe that it is in our power to halt war. I want to believe
that we can silence the raging jets and helicopters forever. But the
part of me that has been humbled to ashes since gazing upon Ali, recognizes
that war, ultimately, is not the real problem. War is merely an inadequate
response, a poorly designed mechanism for solving the larger problems
of human greed and oppression which darken this world.
As I once again sit in Starbucks
at Souq Sharq, comfortably sipping hot chocolate with my Kuwaiti friends
and rejoicing that things are finally back to normal, I watch the
strolling American soldiers with new eyes. They are soooo young these
men and women in the prime of their lives, still with acne on their
faces, still believing in the American dream they were taught in high
school just a year or two ago. Before they were sent to the Iraqi
desert they looked frightened, timid while walking among the Arabs
in the mall. Now they are relaxed, friendly. Having gazed into the
eyes of Arab civilian innocence, they know the Arabs aren't so bad
after all. They know there are more good Arabs than bad Arabs. They
know, in fact, that the Arabs are wonderful people. For this reason,
they sweltered out in the desert heat, almost suffocated in desert
storms, and risked the potential attack of lethal biochemical weapons.
For this reason, they can believe in the killing they may have had
to do, all in hopes of making this region a better place for the Arab
population.
The majority of American
service men and women are completely unaware of the American military
industrial complex. They are unaware of America's selfish reasons
for going to war. They are removed from the battles that occurred
on the streets of the world as protesters tried to jar George Bush's
conscience. Most of them do not know the way in which the United States
insulted the United Nations and how heatedly these UN countries of
conscience blasted us for our willful arrogance. They are young people
who are trying to find their own way, trying to find their own mission
in making this world a better place. And in many ways, they
are our hope, because they have now seen for themselves the goodness
of Arabia, the purity of true Islam, the uncanny way in which human
beings of all races, religions, and regions are so alike. These American
soldiers deserve our respect and our caring.
Still, the part of me that
has been humbled to ashes since gazing upon Ali, recognizes that none
of us, soldiers or peace activists, can find what we are searching
for by ourselves. We are powerless over all of our biases, our political
blindness, our addictions, over all of our habitual patterns. We may
think we have the answer on how to eradicate the axis of evil from
this earth, but ultimately we are only fooling ourselves. Humans can,
by themselves, do nothing. We are absolutely powerless. We are absolutely
powerless. We are absolutely powerless. In my humble opinion, it is
that simple. It is ultimately only the Creator and the magnificent
restorative powers of the universe which can bring beauty and life
back into our world, transforming that which decays into that which
dazzles. It is only God who can dismantle the barricades and the road
blocks which imprison us. Think about 9/11. Think about Gulf War II.
We kid ourselves if we think things will ever really get back to normal.
Pandora's box has been unleashed, human competition for power over
the other is paramount. Detonating buildings here and there
is becoming a routine phenomena.
Our only hope for ending
war, and all the hidden greed and corruption lying beneath that portrayal,
is divine intervention. Whether we bow to Allah five times a day,
attend a worship service, or contemplate the beauty of Earth, invoking
divinity is our only hope for confronting our limitations and recovering
that which is blessing sublime. God with us, in us, through us, and
around us, protecting us from the evil eye, masha'allah, and helping
us to embrace the divine will, insha'allah. If the whole world got
down on its knees one day and begged the Creator, begged the universe
itself, for new life, new solutions to our problems, we just might
take a quantum leap in our consciousness and find a creative alternative
to battlefields and brigades. And then, maybe, we could celebrate
the permanent dismantling of war.